Why is Boeing such a shitty corporation? ROBERT REICH JAN 18, 2024 https://open.substack.com/pub/robertreich/p/why-is-boeing-such-a-shitty-corporation?r=1izlr0&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web

 

Robert Reich

Upgrade to paid

Why is Boeing such a shitty corporation?

ROBERT REICH

JAN 18, 2024

Friends,

My friend Harold Meyerson just wrote this for The American Prospect, and it’s so good and timely that I wanted to share it with you.

In the wake of the midair blowout of a door on a Boeing 737 MAX 9 earlier this month, the lead that Airbus has taken over Boeing in the manufacture and sales of the world’s commercial aircraft has, not surprisingly, grown.

It’s actually been growing for some time: Last year, Airbus delivered 735 new planes to airlines and leasing companies, The New York Times reported, while Boeing delivered just 528. Airbus had an order backlog of 8,600 new planes, against Boeing’s 5,626.

This month’s blowout reinforced the public’s—and consequently, the airlines’—doubts about Boeing’s commitment to safety, which soared after two disastrous crashes of its 737s in 2018 and 2019.

“What used to be a duopoly” in the manufacture of commercial aircraft, Richard Aboulafia of AeroDynamic Advisory told the Times, “has become two-thirds Airbus, one-third Boeing.”

The long descent of Boeing has now become the subject of widespread analysis in the mainstream media. A story last Saturday in The Wall Street Journal began with an account of one Boeing engineer’s white paper in 2001 that warned against the company’s new commitment to outsourcing production of key parts of the aircraft it assembled.

But continuing to produce the parts in-house, with the work done by Boeing’s very experienced and unionized workforce, cut no mustard with Wall Street and the company’s new-model CEOs, who no longer came to their posts from careers in production, but rather from the financial side of the industry.

In 2005, the company sold its Wichita plant to a private equity firm that slashed costs before unloading the plant to Spirit AeroSystems, which has become notorious for its deficient quality inspection practices.

But this fish stunk from the head. Boeing continually objected to what it said were Spirit’s high costs and inability to meet deadlines. As the workers on the shop floor and their union repeatedly noted, this led to rushed production and deficient oversight.

Workers—members of the International Association of Machinists—had “great quality and safety concerns,” one union representative wrote to union leaders, but their concerns were routinely ignored by senior management, the Journal reported.

So how are work practices at Airbus different from those at Boeing? I’m not arguing that Airbus provides a panacea for 21st-century production; a chunk of their own production, for instance, is outsourced as well.

But consider, for starters, who actually owns the two companies. Airbus’s four largest shareholders, in order, are the government of France, the government of Germany, the Capital Research and Management Company, and the government of Spain.

Boeing’s four largest shareholders, in order, are The Vanguard Group, Vanguard Group subfiler, Newport Trust Company, and State Street Corporation (a bank and asset manager). In other words, Airbus’s largest shareholders are mainly politically accountable governments that must pay heed to such public concerns as air safety; Boeing’s are entirely investors in business for profits.

Moreover, as the merger of German, French, and Spanish companies, Airbus production is centered in nations where workers historically and currently have more power than their U.S. counterparts.

Forty-six thousand of Airbus’s roughly 130,000 employees work in the company’s German factories, where workers, by law, routinely discuss production and safety issues with managers in works councils. In the U.S., the Machinists are a union in which workers do have voice and power by American standards, but lack mechanisms like works councils through which management must take at least some heed of their concerns.

In sum, Airbus’s clear leadership over Boeing in matters of flight safety stem in good measure from their differences in ownership and worker power—that is, from the European model of mitigating laissez-faire capitalism with a measure of public and worker power, and from the American model of subjecting corporate policy almost entirely to the demands of investment institutions.

Which, if you track the value of Boeing’s stock, hasn’t worked out that well for those investment institutions, either.

By the way, just how outsourced is Boeing production? Only yesterday, it was revealed the door plug that blew out of the Alaska Airlines plane wasn’t actually produced in Wichita. It was produced in Malaysia, where I very much doubt that workers’ concerns about speed of production and quality oversight have much impact on their managers.

More significantly, the fact that the Malaysian production of the door plug didn’t come to light until yesterday—12 days after the blowout—suggests just how profoundly outsourcing can obscure the public visibility required for corporate accountability.

Subscribe to Robert Reich

Tens of thousands of paid subscribers

Daily newsletter exposing where power lies — and how it's used and abused

Upgrade to paid

149 Likes

·

7 Restacks

16 Comments

Write a comment...

George D Bond Ii

George’s Substack

9 mins ago

Pay the shareholders above all things. Do the at by cutting the workforce and accepting accidents. The cost of doing business.

LIKE (5)

REPLY

SHARE

1 reply

jeff thomas

5 mins ago

Besides the cogent comments in the article, I think no one is looking at the culture changes due to BA's increasing DOD work- which generally is more lucrative, less risky and not subject to commercial swings. The result is over attention and labor allocation to DOD biz at the expense of commercial. Many a US company has downsized their commercial sector to dine at the Pentagon trough...

LIKE (3)

REPLY

SHARE

14 more comments...

Top

New

Community

Why I’m so short

Thoughts about heightism

JUL 11, 2023

 • 

ROBERT REICH

3,146

1,990

Henry Kissinger, 1923-2023. War criminal

Friends, Henry Kissinger has died, at the age of 100. When a former high government official as well known as Kissinger passes, the conventional…

NOV 30, 2023

 • 

ROBERT REICH

2,948

885

The last adult in the room

Joe Biden is shrewd, careful, and calibrated. Almost everyone else on the stage is a wild child.

OCT 19, 2023

 • 

ROBERT REICH

2,846

1,008

See all

Ready for more?

Subscribe

© 2024 Robert Reich

Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice

Start Writing

Get the app

Substack is the home for great writing